anti-christianity.com

Essay · Religion & Human Responsibility

God Gets the Glory, While Humans Abandon Responsibility

On Religious Blindness and Human Suffering


I am a Catholic.

I was baptized and received the Sacrament of Confirmation. And I still believe in the existence of a living God.

But I do not believe that this God is my God.

Those two statements are not contradictory.

To say that a being exists is entirely different from saying that this being loves me, protects me, and intervenes in my life.

I believe that God exists.

But I am not convinced of God's love.

More precisely, when I look at this world, I do not understand how anyone can be so certain of that love.

And for a long time, I have lived with another uncomfortable thought.

Perhaps what should disappear from this world is not belief in God itself, but a form of Christianity that allows human beings to hand their responsibilities over to God.

Believing in God is not, by itself, the problem.

The problem is a faith in which human beings become invisible the moment God enters the picture.

A faith that speaks of divine grace before acknowledging human generosity; that speaks of God's will before confronting human suffering; that discovers God's love in one's own good fortune while discovering God's plan in someone else's tragedy.

That is the faith I criticize.

And I want to ask believers:

Does your faith truly make the world brighter?

Or does it merely make it possible for you to stop looking at the darkness?

My Father Built the House. God Got the Credit.

When I was a child, my grandparents lived in an old thatched-roof house that was practically falling apart. Unlike my family, who lived in the city, they remained there with my uncle.

My uncle was preparing to get married, but the house was far too dilapidated. Eventually, he made my father a promise: if my father built him a new house, he would live there with their parents and take care of them.

My father believed him. And he built the house with his own money.

But after my uncle got married, he changed his mind. When my father told him to keep his promise, my uncle replied:

“Brother, don't fool yourself into thinking you built that house. God simply used you to build it.”

I was a child, but even I knew that something was wrong with that statement.

My father paid for the house. My father decided to build it. My father gave up his own money for the sake of his parents.

And yet the credit somehow belonged to God.

More strangely still, if God moved my father to build the house, why did that same God not move my uncle to keep his promise?

When it was time to receive the house, God had intervened. When it was time to keep a promise, human free will suddenly appeared.

That asymmetry disturbed me.

When something good happens, it is God's grace. When something bad happens, it is human failure.

When a prayer is answered, God has responded. When a prayer is not answered, God has a greater purpose.

When an illness is cured, it is a miracle. When someone dies of that illness, there is a plan beyond our understanding.

When someone survives, God protected them. When someone dies, they have gone to be with God.

In this logic, God can never lose. Whatever happens, faith can produce an explanation for it.

If no possible outcome can ever show a claim to be wrong, on what basis are we so certain that the claim is true?

I am not saying that thanking God is wrong. I am saying that thanking God while refusing to thank my father is wrong.

I am not saying that believing in God's will is itself the problem. The problem is using that belief to erase the responsibilities human beings owe one another.

My father built the house.

That is not theology. It is a fact.

And a person who receives help owes gratitude to the person who gave it.

That is not religion. It is basic human decency.

No faith should be allowed to erase either truth.

God Gets the Miracle. Humans Get the Blame.

I see the same strange structure repeated in Christian language.

A surgery succeeds.

“God saved the patient.”

Then where is the surgeon? Where is the nurse who stayed awake through the night watching over the patient? Where are the researchers whose decades of work made the treatment possible?

One can say that all of them were instruments of God. Fine.

Then reverse the question.

Another patient dies in the same hospital. Was that death also the result of God using the doctors as instruments?

Most believers would not put it that way.

God appears prominently in success, but steps backward when the outcome is failure.

Divine intervention is invoked to explain good outcomes, while human limitation, free will, natural law, or unknowable providence is invoked to explain bad ones.

God receives the glory but not the responsibility. Humans surrender the credit but keep the blame.

If we claim that God intervenes when good things happen, should we not also explain why He does not intervene when terrible things happen?

If a child survives cancer and we thank God, should we not be able to speak about that same God to the parents in the next hospital room who prayed just as desperately and still lost their child?

If the survival of the first child proves God's love, what does the death of the second child prove?

At this point, someone may say, “We cannot understand God's will.” But that creates an even deeper problem.

If we cannot understand God's will, how can we confidently declare that the first event was an expression of God's love?

When tragedy occurs, we say, “Human beings cannot understand God's will.” But when something good happens, we say, “God helped me because He loves me.”

So do we truly not know God's will?

Or do we believe we know it only when events happen to favor us?

Could You Say the Same Thing to a Starving Child?

Theology has spent centuries explaining suffering: free will, original sin, trials, providence, a greater good, a divine plan beyond human understanding.

Thousands of explanations have been offered.

But I think one simple question matters more than elaborate theology:

Could you say those words while looking directly into the face of someone who is dying?

Could you sit before the parents of a starving child and say, “God has a purpose”?

Could you tell parents whose child was killed in a bombing, “There must be a plan beyond our understanding”?

Could you tell someone dying because they cannot afford medical treatment, “Perhaps a greater good will come from your suffering”?

If you can say those things, then I have another question.

Who needs that explanation?

The dying person?

Or the believer who needs to continue believing that the God watching all of this remains a God of love?

Theologies that explain other people's suffering can become defenses for believers whose faith is threatened by the sight of suffering.

This is where faith can become cruel. Preserving one's worldview becomes more important than confronting another person's reality.

A starving person does not need the meaning of hunger. They need food.

A sick person does not need the purpose of suffering. They need treatment.

A person under bombardment does not need an explanation of providence. They need the bombing to stop.

And perhaps the first thing a person in despair needs is not a theologian, but another human being who refuses to leave their side.

“God Did It” — and the Danger Hidden in Those Words

Someone performs an act of kindness and says, “I did nothing. God did it.”

It sounds humble. And sometimes it is genuine humility.

But something changes when that way of thinking is applied to the good deeds of other people.

I am free to give God the credit for the good that I myself have done.

But I do not have the right to take the credit for someone else's kindness toward me and hand it over to God.

That is not humility. It is changing the recipient of gratitude.

If someone helps me, I owe that person gratitude. That person gave their time, spent their money, took the risk, or sacrificed something for me.

I may also see God's will behind that act. But the human being standing before me does not therefore disappear.

If anything, genuine faith should make us capable of saying: “I thank God. And I thank you, the person who helped me.”

Yet the opposite often happens.

Human goodness becomes God's achievement. Human wrongdoing becomes human free will.

The glory rises upward. The responsibility remains below.

That is precisely what I object to.

Where Is God?

Christianity says that God is omnipotent. It also says that God is good. And it says that God loves humanity.

If so, the existence of evil and suffering is not a peripheral question. It is one of the central questions of faith.

If God does not know about human suffering, He is not omniscient.

If He knows but lacks the power to prevent it, He is not omnipotent.

If He knows and has the power to prevent it but does not, then we inevitably ask why.

Christian theology has offered many answers.

But “human beings cannot fully understand God's will” does not solve the problem. It postpones the question.

And postponing the question can itself be intellectually honest.

“I don't know.”

I respect that answer.

The problem begins when someone says “I don't know” and then immediately claims to know with certainty that God loves us.

We do not know why suffering was permitted. We do not know why the child died. We do not know why the prayer went unanswered. We do not know why a decent person endured something horrific.

But somehow we know that God loves you.

What is the basis for certainty about that final sentence?

I Believe in God. That Is Why I Ask.

I do not deny God. I believe He exists.

That makes the question more serious for me, not less.

You cannot demand an answer from a god you believe does not exist.

But if you believe God exists, you begin to ask:

Where were You?

Were You beside the child who starved to death?

Were You beside the person killed by a bomb?

Were You beside the patient who gave up treatment because they could not afford it?

If You were there, what did You do?

And if You did nothing, why?

I do not know the answer. Perhaps I will die without ever knowing it.

So at the very least, I do not want human beings to hand over their own responsibilities to God.

If someone is hungry, human beings must feed them. If someone is sick, human beings must treat them. If someone is being treated unjustly, human beings must stand beside them.

If war is killing people, human beings must work to stop the war.

And if another person shows me kindness, I should first thank that human being.

There will still be time to thank God afterward.

When Faith Anesthetizes the Conscience

Faith can make human beings better.

There are people who, because of religious conviction, spend their lives feeding the poor, caring for the sick, and giving away their time and wealth.

I do not deny them. I respect them.

But precisely because such people exist, another question becomes unavoidable.

If the same faith gives one person a reason to sacrifice and another person a reason to evade responsibility, where does the difference come from?

I think the difference may have less to do with whether God exists than with how human beings use what they believe.

If faith causes a person to question their own actions constantly, it can awaken the conscience.

But faith can become dangerous when it gives someone the certainty: “I am on the right side. God is with me. What I am doing is God's will.”

Because when a person becomes absolutely certain that they are right, one of the first things to disappear is self-doubt.

And conviction without self-doubt can become dangerous, whether it is religious or political.

Looking at January 6, 2021

At this point, I think of a form of blindness that appears outside religion.

On January 6, 2021, while Congress was meeting to certify the Electoral College vote, a mob breached the United States Capitol. Congressional proceedings were disrupted, lawmakers were evacuated, and law-enforcement officers were assaulted and injured—facts documented through official investigations and judicial proceedings.

Political interpretations of January 6 remain deeply contested in American public life.

But whatever one's political position, one principle should not change:

The fact that you were not harmed does not erase the harm suffered by someone else.

I do not consider this a problem belonging to only one political camp.

The more tightly people bind their identity to something they strongly believe in, the harder it can become to accept facts that threaten that belief.

The same can happen in religion.

The question comes before what we believe:

Do we begin denying visible facts and other people's suffering in order to protect that belief?

Belief can be a tool for interpreting reality.

It must not become a tool for deleting reality.

The Pastor I Met on the Subway

About twenty years ago, I encountered a pastor preaching on the subway during my morning commute.

He continued preaching in the same carriage for a long time. One passenger told him to stop. The pastor did not stop.

Eventually, the passenger became enraged and moved toward the pastor. A large man standing beside the pastor restrained him.

Then the pastor said:

“I certainly feel safe with you here, Deacon.”

I was furious.

And in the end, I too resorted to violence.

I overpowered the deacon first and threw the pastor to the floor.

Today, I do not justify what I did.

Another person's wrongdoing does not give me the right to use violence.

In fact, that experience allows me to state the question of responsibility more clearly.

I can believe that the pastor behaved wrongly and still acknowledge responsibility for my own actions.

His wrongdoing does not erase mine.

That is what responsibility means.

And I demand the same standard from faith.

Do not selectively declare that what is good belongs to God while what is bad belongs to humanity. Look honestly at the consequences produced by your beliefs and your actions.

Is Faith Really Making the World Brighter?

Christians say that faith teaches love, forgiveness, sacrifice, and mercy.

Then I would rather look at reality than at a theology book.

I want to look at the table of the hungry.

I want to look beside the bed of the sick.

I want to look at the face of someone who has lost a family to war.

I want to see how believers treat people whose beliefs, identities, or lives differ profoundly from their own.

The value of faith may be revealed more clearly by how certainty about God causes someone to treat other human beings than by how confidently that person speaks about God.

Going to church every week is easy.

Talking about God's love among people who share the same beliefs is easy.

What is difficult is treating the suffering of someone entirely unlike yourself as though it matters to you.

More difficult still is admitting it when your own church, religion, or religious leader has done wrong.

And perhaps the most difficult thing of all is learning to see the human being before the doctrine.

Before Speaking of God's Glory

I believe in God.

But I do not believe God's existence replaces human responsibility.

I believe that God exists.

But I do not believe every good thing human beings do must be transferred to God's account.

If a human being saves another human being, thank the human being.

If a doctor saves a patient, acknowledge the doctor's work.

If a firefighter walks into flames, acknowledge that person's courage.

If a parent sacrifices for a child, acknowledge that parent's love.

And when someone does wrong, that person must take responsibility.

The name of God must not become an eraser for human responsibility.

I still remember the words I heard as a child:

“Don't fool yourself into thinking you built that house.”

No.

My father built that house.

If you want to believe that God moved my father to do it, believe that.

But it does not erase the fact that my father paid for it. It does not erase his sacrifice. And it does not erase the responsibility of the person who received that help to keep his promise.

Perhaps the question I have carried for decades has always been just one question:

Why does God get the glory while humans abandon responsibility?

If faith makes human beings humbler, I respect that faith.

If faith makes human beings more responsible, I respect that faith.

If faith makes people more sensitive to the suffering of others, I respect that faith.

But if faith erases human goodness, blurs human responsibility, covers the suffering of others in the language of explanation, and finally seals every contradiction with the words “God's will,” then I struggle to find a reason to respect that faith.

Before speaking of God's glory, look at human suffering.

Before speaking of God's will, do what human beings must do.

Before thanking God, first thank the human being who helped you.

And do not speak of God's love while doing nothing in the face of another person's suffering.

At that moment, perhaps what you are protecting is God.

But perhaps what you are really protecting is your own peace of mind.

I believe in God.

That is why I ask.

Whose God is your God?

Is He a God of love only when you are happy?

A living God only when your prayers are answered?

A God who intervenes only when something good happens to you?

Then who was He to the child who starved to death?

Who was He to the person who died while praying?

Who was He to the person who lost an entire family to war?

If you cannot answer those questions, that is all right.

I cannot answer them either.

But then let us admit that we do not know.

And before filling what we do not know with the words “God's will,” let us begin with what we do know.

There is a human being who is suffering.

That human being needs the help of another human being.

We do not need theology to know that.

Reduce human suffering before trying to prove the existence of God.

At least for that task, we do not need to know God's will.